423 Whalley Avenue | New Haven N/A

$1,395,000 | 6 Baths (5 Full, 1 Half) | 6,165 Sq. Ft.

Prime Mixed Use Investment Opportunity in the Heart of New Haven! ***Sale is for the Real Estate only not the business*** Welcome to 423 Whalley Avenue, a well maintained 6 unit mixed use property offering exceptional income potential and strong value add upside. Ideally situated on the corner of Whalley Avenue and Ellsworth Avenue, this 6,100+ sq ft asset features 4 residential apartments and 2 commercial units, currently occupied by the long established Damato's Seafood Restaurant. The residential unit mix includes: * Two (2) - 2BR / 1BA units * One (1) - 3BR / 1BA unit * One (1) - 4BR / 2BA unit (vacant, offering immediate owner user or rent up opportunity) All residential units-aside from the top floor 4BR-are fully occupied, with below market rents providing substantial room for revenue growth. The commercial spaces are fully leased and operating as Damato's Restaurant, a long time neighborhood favorite. Damato's will do a lease back on the space they currently occupy. With a pro forma NOI supporting a potential 7% CAP rate, this property offers both stability and future upside for investors. Additional amenities include a 3 car detached garage, plus a fenced in rear parking lot providing secure parking for tenants and commercial patrons. Whether you're expanding your portfolio or seeking a high performing mixed use asset, 423 Whalley Avenue delivers location, scale, and immediate value add potential in one of New Haven's most active corridors. SmartMLS 24154449

Directions to property: GPS

MLS Listing ID: 
SmartMLS 24154449
Building Details
Details about the building on a property.
Stories: 
3
Year Built: 
1976
Living Area: 
6,165
Construction
Foundation Details: 
Concrete
Roof: 
Asphalt Shingle
Room Details
Details about the rooms in the building.
Total Rooms: 
0
Total Bedrooms: 
0
Total Bathrooms: 
6
Total Full-Bathrooms: 
5
Total Half-Bathrooms: 
1
Utilities
Information about utilities available on the property.
Heating System: 
Hot Water
Heating System Fuel: 
Natural Gas
Cooling System: 
Central Air, Window Unit
Water Source: 
Public Water Connected
Sewer: 
Public Sewer Connected
Lot/Land Details
Details about the lots and land features included on the property.
Acres: 
0.25
Waterfront: 
0
Public Record
Parcel Number: 
1256725
Annual Tax: 
$18,516.00
Property Zoning: 
BA
Listing Dates
Dates involved in the transaction.
Listing Entry Date/Time: 
3/3/2026
Contract Details
Details about the listing contract.
Possession: 
Negotiable
Listing Participants
Participants (agents, offices, etc.) in the transaction.
Listing Agent Name: 
Joe Scarpellino
Listing Office Name: 
Coldwell Banker Realty